debate: The end of the Organisation?

As with the recent open thread for lurkers, this post is one from a series which adopts different blogging patterns. At the suggestion of the format is that of a debate, and the topic we have chosen is “The end of the organisation?” after an article by Michael Gilbert. Josien Kapma has kicked off the debate by arguing in favour of the premise that organisations are going to change unrecognisably in response to technology improvements in the means of communications, namely the internet. “The organizations of the future will not look like the organizations of today.”

So I shall adopt the contrary view and oppose the proposition.

I disagree that organisations are shaped by their communications. For me this is a secondary consideration, with the main shaping force being that of economics. I shall argue that as long as the fundamental economic relationships which lie at the base of society remain unchanged then nothing revolutionary is going to happen. A change in the mode of communication will cause big upheavals in some of the light industries which specialise in knowledge work, in publishing and media, that is certain. But these industries are not crucial to the means of sustaining our lives.
The more important work of providing food, shelter, health, transport, energy and infrastucture will continue pretty much the same, regardless of what is happening in the online world.

Ah but I hear objections already. This is surely cheating! For some people, and indeed the scope of the pertinent essay, the concern is with the so-called “non-profit” organisations, the civil society, and my arguments have flown straight outside the boundaries of the arena.

I will also argue that in an economy which is run for and by the owners of big business, the values which are predominant at all levels are those which support the continuation of the system based on free market economics and the private ownership of the means of prodution. The non-profits are not islands of activity which work in isolation. They are part of the wider society, their clients and employees have to live in the current world and their values and economic relations end up reflecting those of the corporations to defend the status quo.

Technorati Tags:

This entry was posted in Blogs and community and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to debate: The end of the Organisation?

  1. Hi Andy, been thinking about this too, and was intending to blog, but thankfully you have done this, so I can comment here. I don’t see it being the end to organisations at all, I forsee a widening of the vibrant society we already have and have had historically for many years.

    Grassroots community action will always still happen. With or without technology. New organisations will be born in response to a need, other organisations will grow and maybe widen their work, or stay as they are, some will have acheived their mission and no longer be needed… It will all keep happening. That’s what the nonprofit sector does and is about. Some will use technologies to support and enhance their work, and reach out to wider audiences, others don’t and sometimes don’t always need to, technology isn’t always relevant to making things happen. All pends on the purpose and need, and what they want to achieve to fulfil their mission. I feel that sometimes as evangalists of technology we can sometimes become detached from the real nuts and bolts of everyday society that takes place supporting a whole communities daily life for all ages (young to old). Technology can support, but musn’t be seen as the be all and end all. The ‘techno’ bit is just a tool, not the reason.

    Technology enhances bringing the ability to enhance participation, have a voice in different discussions has created an additional strand of community action. It does and can still happen without technology too. In addition to the traditional structures and activity, some may evolve into different more technology based/driven communities, and new activity will be created partly because of the ability of technology to pool people together. But you’ll never lose the grass roots activity or ‘traditional’ organisation that runs successfully and always has done. That will always be there.

    Our evolving and new emerging communities and organisations will all add to what we already have and make the nonprofit sector even more innovative and diverse as it is today.

    rant over…

  2. Hi Andy, just sent you a mail… didn’t know you beat me!! will read it carefully..

  3. Pingback: That photo in Here Comes Everybody (Flickr)

  4. Pingback: The end of management (General)

Comments are closed.